renato97/ableton-mcp-ai
1
0
Fork 0
Code Issues Pull Requests Actions Packages Projects Releases 1 Wiki Activity
Files
6d080d43b3c869e644c709f0b13bead55fe66559
ableton-mcp-ai/KIMI_K2_ACTIVE_HANDOFF.md

18 KiB
Raw Blame History

Kimi K2 Active Handoff

Si otro documento contradice este, usa este archivo y despues valida con codigo y runtime.

Sprint activo

  • C:\ProgramData\Ableton\Live 12 Suite\Resources\MIDI Remote Scripts\docs\SPRINT_v0.1.10_NEXT.md

Arquitectura activa

  • Cliente MCP -> mcp_wrapper.py -> AbletonMCP_AI/AbletonMCP_AI/MCP_Server/server.py
  • Ableton Live -> AbletonMCP_AI/__init__.py -> abletonmcp_init.py
  • _Framework/ es el shim minimo para que el runtime no dependa de imports rotos

Estado real verificado a 2026-03-30

  • server.py tiene tools async y compila
  • sample_selector.py tiene section context, same-pack y joint scoring
  • reference_listener.py ahora setea contexto por seccion y pasa section_kind/section_energy en seleccion por variante
  • reference_listener.py ya carga el indice real de MIDI/presets para resolver hints armonicos
  • reference_listener.py ya devuelve micro_stem_summary, harmonic_instrument_hints, midi_preset_index_stats y synth_loop_hint
  • temp\smoke_test_async.py existe y ya no apunta a un SERVER_PATH roto
  • temp\smoke_test_async_report.json es la ultima evidencia runtime guardada disponible del smoke test:
    • connection_check: PASS
    • launch_async_job: PASS
    • verify_tracks_created: PASS
    • poll_job_status: timeout a 300s
  • .gitignore vuelve a ignorar temp/ sin esconder scripts globalmente
  • feedback real del usuario: las ultimas generaciones suenan desordenadas, con sonidos buenos pero sin identidad melodica clara
  • referencia canonica nueva: docs\REFERENCE_TRACK_EJEMPLO_ANALYSIS.md
  • referencia micro stems nueva: docs\REFERENCE_TRACK_EJEMPLO_MICRO_STEMS.md
  • enfoque tecnico nuevo: docs\MICRO_STEMS_APPROACH.md
  • benchmark real de providers anthropic-compatible: docs\ANTHROPIC_COMPAT_PROVIDER_CHECK_2026-03-30.md
  • dashboard local de Ralph listo para usar:
    • ralph\scripts\Start-RalphDashboard.ps1
    • ralph\gui\app.py
    • ralph\state\current_run.json
    • ralph\state\events.jsonl
  • reporte corregido por Codex:
    • docs\SPRINT_v0.1.9_IMPLEMENTATION_REPORT.md
  • nota de arquitectura: la vieja idea de pasar current_kind/current_energy en reference_listener.py:3862 no es un fix suficiente, porque esa seleccion ocurre antes del loop de secciones
  • AUDITORY VALIDATION PENDING (2026-03-30): Se genero track reggaeton @ 95 BPM, 201 tracks creados, job timeout a 300s, necesita escucha real para validar coherencia musical
  • correccion validada por Codex: server.py ahora persiste musical_theme en manifest y pack_brain penaliza mas fuerte conflictos armonicos entre bass y music
  • correcciones nuevas validadas por Codex:
    • reference_listener.py ahora construye micro_stems y micro_stem_summary
    • reference_listener.py ya usa ese resumen para rerankear matches globales
    • detect_reference_sections() ya no rompe con tempo ndarray de librosa
    • synth_loop ya no acepta archivos vocales
    • _extract_pack() ya no considera carpetas genericas como 20 One Shots un pack dominante
    • sample_selector.record_section_selection() ya acepta dicts
  • ultimo manifest auditado por Codex (session_id = fadbe771353b):
    • budget logico: 11/12
    • core/optional: 55%
    • same-pack ratio: 53%
    • tonal consistency: 10/10 samples en conflicto contra Fm
    • redundant layers: 16

Lo que SI esta demostrado

  • MCP por stdio
  • runtime de Live cargando abletonmcp_init.py
  • get_session_info y get_tracks cuando Live esta abierto
  • tests unitarios del selector pasando
  • progreso real en wiring por seccion dentro de reference_listener.py
  • evidencia runtime nueva:
    • temp\ejemplo_micro_stems_report.json
    • temp\ejemplo_arrangement_plan_validation.json
    • temp\v018_harmonic_resolution_validation.json

Lo que NO esta demostrado todavia

  • que SampleSelector._calculate_joint_score() afecte la generacion real end-to-end
  • que el flujo real emita JOINT_SCORE en logs de una generacion
  • que generate_song_async y generate_track_async esten validados con Live real de punta a punta
  • si el timeout async actual es lentitud real o cuelgue del job
  • que groove extraction este influyendo de forma musicalmente util en un track generado
  • que el sistema tenga coherencia musical real entre bass, chords, lead, vocals y sections
  • que el sistema pueda materializar en runtime un hook MIDI/preset dominante como piano/keys/pluck

Archivos que debes leer primero

  1. C:\ProgramData\Ableton\Live 12 Suite\Resources\MIDI Remote Scripts\KIMI_K2_BOOTSTRAP.md
  2. C:\ProgramData\Ableton\Live 12 Suite\Resources\MIDI Remote Scripts\KIMI_K2_START_HERE.md
  3. C:\ProgramData\Ableton\Live 12 Suite\Resources\MIDI Remote Scripts\CLAUDE.md
  4. C:\ProgramData\Ableton\Live 12 Suite\Resources\MIDI Remote Scripts\docs\REFERENCE_TRACK_EJEMPLO_ANALYSIS.md
  5. C:\ProgramData\Ableton\Live 12 Suite\Resources\MIDI Remote Scripts\docs\REFERENCE_TRACK_EJEMPLO_MICRO_STEMS.md
  6. C:\ProgramData\Ableton\Live 12 Suite\Resources\MIDI Remote Scripts\docs\MICRO_STEMS_APPROACH.md
  7. C:\ProgramData\Ableton\Live 12 Suite\Resources\MIDI Remote Scripts\docs\ANTHROPIC_COMPAT_PROVIDER_CHECK_2026-03-30.md
  8. C:\ProgramData\Ableton\Live 12 Suite\Resources\MIDI Remote Scripts\docs\CONSOLIDADO_v0.1.8_PARA_CODEX.md
  9. C:\ProgramData\Ableton\Live 12 Suite\Resources\MIDI Remote Scripts\docs\SPRINT_v0.1.9_NEXT.md

Archivos activos mas importantes

  • C:\ProgramData\Ableton\Live 12 Suite\Resources\MIDI Remote Scripts\abletonmcp_init.py
  • C:\ProgramData\Ableton\Live 12 Suite\Resources\MIDI Remote Scripts\mcp_wrapper.py
  • C:\ProgramData\Ableton\Live 12 Suite\Resources\MIDI Remote Scripts\AbletonMCP_AI\AbletonMCP_AI\MCP_Server\server.py
  • C:\ProgramData\Ableton\Live 12 Suite\Resources\MIDI Remote Scripts\AbletonMCP_AI\AbletonMCP_AI\MCP_Server\reference_listener.py
  • C:\ProgramData\Ableton\Live 12 Suite\Resources\MIDI Remote Scripts\AbletonMCP_AI\AbletonMCP_AI\MCP_Server\sample_selector.py
  • C:\ProgramData\Ableton\Live 12 Suite\Resources\MIDI Remote Scripts\AbletonMCP_AI\AbletonMCP_AI\MCP_Server\song_generator.py
  • C:\ProgramData\Ableton\Live 12 Suite\Resources\MIDI Remote Scripts\temp\smoke_test_async.py

Reglas duras

  • usa PowerShell, no bash
  • usa rutas absolutas de Windows en docs
  • no declares exito por compilacion sola
  • no declares exito por logs esperados o inventados
  • si contradicen diff, codigo y doc, gana el codigo
  • si contradicen codigo y runtime, gana el runtime
  • no intentes arreglar la coherencia con mas tracks; primero reduce, ancla y simplifica
  • no fuerces audio si el rol armonico correcto vive en MIDI o presets; primero reconoce esa limitacion

Comandos utiles

python temp\smoke_test_async.py --use-track
python AbletonMCP_AI\AbletonMCP_AI\MCP_Server\tests\test_sample_selector.py
Get-Content "$env:APPDATA\Ableton\Live 12.0.15\Preferences\Log.txt" -Tail 120
rg -n "SECTION_CONTEXT|JOINT_SCORE|smoke_test_async.py" .

Auditory Validation Report

Track Generated: 2026-03-30 12:48 Genre: reggaeton (perreo style) BPM: 95 Key: Am (auto-selected) Tracks Created: 201 total (194 reported by smoke test) Test Result: FAILED (timeout at 300s)

Technical Issues Observed

  • ZAIJudges API: 429 Too Many Requests (exhausted all retries)
  • Audio Resampling: Multiple "System error" failures on file creation
  • Job Stage: Stuck at generating_config stage
  • Timeout: 300s max polls reached, job did not complete
  • Track Muting: Extensive mute operations at end (cleanup pattern)

What Was Materialized

Based on logs, the following was created before timeout:

  • Multiple audio tracks with Simpler devices loaded
  • Audio arrangement patterns placed on timeline
  • Bus structure: DRUM BUS, BASS BUS, MUSIC BUS, VOCAL LATIN BUS, FX BUS
  • Cue points created (4 markers)
  • Section variants: intro, build, break, outro configured
  • Gain staging applied with latin style adjustments

What Sounds Coherent (Technical Assessment)

  • Bus structure is logically organized by role
  • Section variants have distinct drum/bass/melodic patterns
  • Same-pack selection logic appears to be triggering
  • Latin vocal bus suggests pack coherence for reggaeton genre

What Sounds Random (Technical Assessment)

  • Job timeout prevented full section-by-section materialization
  • ZAI API failures mean no harmonic coherence validation occurred
  • Audio resample failures (0 derived layers created)
  • Cannot verify bass-chords-lead relationships without completion

Too Much / Overcrowded

  • Track count: 201 (significantly exceeds typical 12-track budget)
  • Many tracks may be empty or partially configured due to timeout
  • Needs cleanup/validation to determine actual populated tracks

Missing

  • Complete generation (job timeout)
  • Audio resample FX layers (reverse, riser, downlifter, stutter)
  • Final arrangement view population verification
  • Actual audio playback validation

Pack Coherence

  • Dominant pack: Midilatino samples detected in logs
  • Riser FX attempted: Midilatino_Holanda_F_Min_108BPM_Riser.wav
  • Texture attempted: Midilatino_Gracias_C#_Min_102BPM_Texture.wav
  • Suggests pack-based selection is working for reggaeton genre

Overall Judgment

Score: N/A (incomplete generation) Verdict: PENDING - Requires user auditory review

Note: As an AI, I cannot actually listen to the audio. This technical assessment shows the generation infrastructure works but hit timeout/API limits. The user must listen to the resulting track in Ableton to judge actual musical coherence.

Next Steps for Coherence Validation

  1. Listen to the generated track in Ableton Live
  2. Check if sections feel related (intro -> build -> break -> outro flow)
  3. Verify bass fits with chords (harmonic alignment)
  4. Check if lead relates to bass/chords (motif continuity)
  5. Evaluate pack coherence (do all sounds feel from same "world")
  6. Rate overall musicality 1-10

Technical Fixes Needed

  • Increase async job timeout or optimize generation speed
  • Fix ZAIJudges API rate limiting or add fallback
  • Fix audio resampling "System error" (file permissions/path issues)
  • Add progress checkpointing to resume interrupted generations
  • Reduce track budget to prevent overcrowding

Prioridad actual

La prioridad ya no es “generar mas cosas”.

La prioridad es:

  1. mismo centro tonal
  2. misma hook family
  3. menos capas
  4. menos cambio de palette entre secciones
  5. acercarse estructuralmente a ejemplo.mp3

Validation Report - 2026-03-30

Status: PARTIAL / NEEDS FIXES
Report: docs/VALIDATION_REPORT_EJEMPLO_2026-03-30.md

Quick Summary

  • ✅ Ableton running (port 9877 active)
  • ✅ Micro-stem analysis working (33 sections, ss_rnbl dominant)
  • ✅ Sample library indexed (510 samples)
  • ✅ Track generation started (95 BPM, Dm key)
  • ❌ Generation timeout (300s limit reached)
  • ❌ Track budget exceeded (165 tracks vs 12 limit)
  • ❌ Key mismatch (generation: Dm, reference: Am)
  • ⚠️ Coherence metrics unavailable (manifest not generated)

Critical Issues to Fix

  1. Timeout: Generation must complete <300s or increase limit
  2. Budget: Must enforce 12-track limit, remove redundant layers
  3. Key: Force match with reference (Am not Dm)
  4. Manifest: Capture coherence scores for validation

What Passed

  • Micro-stem extraction & analysis
  • Sample matching by pack-family (ss_rnbl)
  • Section-aware generation (intro/build/break/outro)
  • Bus routing (DRUM/BASS/MUSIC/VOCAL/FX)
  • Audio materialization in Ableton

What Failed

  • Full generation completion
  • Track budget compliance
  • Key consistency with reference
  • Coherence metric capture

User Action Required

  1. Listen to generated track in Ableton
  2. Rate: similarity to ejemplo.mp3 (1-10)
  3. Verify: bass-chords-lead alignment
  4. Confirm: pack coherence (do sounds feel related?)

Next Technical Sprint

  1. Fix generation timeout (optimize or extend)
  2. Enforce 12-track budget strictly
  3. Lock generation key to reference key
  4. Re-run smoke test with --use-track --genre reggaeton --bpm 95
  5. Validate coherence metrics from manifest

Validation Report v0.1.9 - 2026-03-30

Status: FAIL
Validation Files:

  • temp/v019_reference_locked_generation.json
  • temp/v019_runtime_summary.json
  • temp/smoke_report_reggaeton.json

Executive Summary

Generation completed with CRITICAL failures. Ableton was running and accepting commands, but reference-based generation was NOT possible due to smoke_test_async.py lacking --reference support. Track budget enforcement failed catastrophically (100 tracks vs 16 limit). Job timed out after 180s.

What Passed ✓

  • Ableton running (port 9877 LISTENING)
  • Remote Script responding to commands
  • Connection check passed (95 BPM, 72 tracks, 6 scenes)
  • Async job launched successfully (job_id=e3fb72575548)
  • Bus configuration created (DRUM, BASS, MUSIC, VOCAL, FX)
  • Pack coherence maintained (SentimientoLatino2025 dominant)
  • Sample selection working (17 samples used from reggaeton library)

What Failed ✗

  • Reference file usage (smoke_test_async.py lacks --reference flag)
  • Track budget enforcement (100 tracks vs 16 limit = 525% over budget)
  • Generation completion (timeout at 180s, stage=generating_config)
  • MIDI hook creation (not present in output)
  • Manifest persistence (not saved for this session)
  • Audio resample generation (system errors on file operations)

Critical Issues Found

  1. Budget Enforcement Broken: Planned 15 tracks, created 100 tracks
  2. Missing Reference Support: Cannot test reference-locked generation via smoke test
  3. Timeout Too Aggressive: 180s insufficient for full materialization
  4. Audio Resample Failures: Cannot generate derived FX layers
  5. Manifest Not Updated: No record of this generation in manifests DB

Evidence Summary

  • Tracks Created: 100 (51 midi, 49 audio) vs budget of 16
  • Generation Time: 183.54s before timeout
  • Key Used: Am (requested 95 BPM, but manifest shows 99 BPM from earlier run)
  • Dominant Pack: SentimientoLatino2025 (reggaeton)
  • Sample Usage: 17 samples from reggaeton library

Verdict: FAIL

Primary Blockers:

  1. Cannot test reference-locked generation without --reference support
  2. Track budget enforcement completely failed
  3. Job timeout prevents full validation

Next Sprint Recommendations

  1. URGENT: Add --reference flag to smoke_test_async.py OR use reference_listener_test.py
  2. CRITICAL: Fix track budget enforcement - 100 tracks is unacceptable
  3. HIGH: Extend timeout or optimize generation speed
  4. MEDIUM: Fix audio resample system errors
  5. MEDIUM: Ensure manifest is saved even on timeout

User Action Required

  1. Listen to generated track in Ableton (100 tracks present)
  2. Evaluate if budget enforcement failure is audible (overcrowding)
  3. Manually test reference-based generation using reference_listener_test.py
  4. Report: Does the track sound cohesive despite technical failures?

End-to-End Validation Report v0.1.12 - COMPLETED - 2026-04-01

Status: COMPLETED - Validation Executed, Issues Found
Validation File: docs/SPRINT_v0.1.12_VALIDATION_REPORT.md
Session ID: 7f8c9243285a

Executive Summary

Sprint v0.1.12 end-to-end validation completed successfully. MCP connection restored by restarting Ableton. Validation revealed budget enforcement gaps and MIDI hook materialization failure, but core JOINT_SCORE and harmonic coherence systems are working as designed.

What Passed ✓

  • MCP connection restored (port 9877 LISTENING)
  • Async job completed (279s, 94 polls)
  • Reference analysis working (ejemplo.mp3: Am, 99.384 BPM, ss_rnbl family)
  • JOINT_SCORE governing selection (palette-41 score=28.106)
  • Harmonic family lock working (pluck across all phrases)
  • Harmonic hints propagated through all 4 function levels
  • 35 tracks created in Ableton (17 MIDI, 18 audio)
  • Coherence report generated (score: 4.3/10)
  • Smoke test 6/6 passed

Critical Issues Found ✗

  • Budget exceeded: 35 tracks vs 16 limit (119% over)
  • MIDI hook failed: Could not materialize due to budget limit
  • Pack coherence low: 12% from dominant pack vs 60% target
  • Duplicate resample layers: REVERSE FX and RISER created twice
  • Selection reasons missing: Layer-level audit not in manifest

Key Evidence

PRIMARY_FAMILY_FROM_REFERENCE: pluck -> pluck
FAMILY_LOCK: Primary family set to pluck
FAMILY_COHERENT: All 7 phrases use pluck
BUDGET_COMPLETE: 5/12 tracks used (budget layer)
TRACK_CREATED: 15/16 tracks (blueprint layer)
Materialization complete: 16 tracks created, 2 errors (hard limit)
[MIDI_HOOK_ERROR] Failed to materialize: Hard budget limit reached

Root Cause Analysis

The issue is not the scoring logic (JOINT_SCORE works correctly). The issue is the materialization phase creating tracks before budget enforcement:

  1. Blueprint phase: Creates 15 MIDI tracks (before budget check)
  2. Budget check: Hard limit at 16 prevents audio layers 16-17
  3. Result: 35 tracks total (15 MIDI + 18 audio + duplicates)

Sprint v0.1.12 Completion

  • ✅ Task 1: JOINT_SCORE governs selection - COMPLETE
  • ✅ Task 2: Harmonic coherence contract - COMPLETE
  • ⚠️ Task 3: Selection reasons in manifest - PARTIAL (pack-level only)
  • ✅ Task 4: Coherence tests - COMPLETE (11 tests)
  • ⚠️ Task 5: End-to-end validation - COMPLETE with issues documented

Next Sprint Priorities (v0.1.13)

  1. Budget-first architecture: Check budget BEFORE creating any tracks
  2. Hook prioritization: Reserve slot for MIDI hook before budget fills
  3. Manifest audit trail: Persist layer-level selection reasons
  4. Pack coherence enforcement: Select from detected dominant pack (ss_rnbl)

Previous Validation Report v0.1.2 - 2026-04-01 (SUPERSEDED)

Status: BLOCKED - MCP Connection Failure (RESOLVED)

This section kept for historical reference. Connection issue was resolved by restarting Ableton Live.

Reference in New Issue View Git Blame Copy Permalink